It now should be more than clear to all that Josh Hamilton is the American League MVP. There should be no question. He is the true 5 tool player. Hits for power and average, runs bases expertly, fields as good as any in the game and don't try to take an extra base on him, he will gun you down. Sadly, I don't believe he will win the MVP.
Over half of the voters reside within a half hour drive of the east coast. They love the Yankees Robinson Cano. It may even go to someone for the (satan)Rays. Possibly Miguel Cabrera or another midwest player. I can't see them voting for a west coast player this year, unless they try to give Trevor Cahill both the MVP and the Cy Young, which is doubtful. They won't vote for a Ranger.
Speaking of Cy Young, does Cliff Lee want to be here? Doesn't seem like it. Weather, the park, travel requirements all have nothing to do with it. He wanted to play for the Yankees. He was keyed up to go and then the trade fell through. I'm not saying he's intentionally throwing it, he just isn't into it and may well be becoming a liability.
Let's face it, baseball and basketball aren't like football. The majority of football players will play hard for the team they are on. There is no majority clamoring to play in Dallas or Pittsburgh or San Francisco or some team seen as a historically and drastically dominant as an organization. In basketball, over half the league would rather be in Los Angeles, Boston or just on the east coast. It's for those teams that they try hardest. Well over half of baseball players want to play for the Yankees and about half would have the Red Sox or Dodgers be a close second.
What I don't get is why. For the Yankees especially, you are likely to be just another guy. Look at the Yankees history. How many current Yankees are going to be seen as all timers? Jeter and Rivera. Do you remember Jason Giambi as a Yankee or an A. Dave Winfield as a Yankee or a Padre? A-rod as a Yankee or a PED diva? And the list goes on. So many players have a chance to be beloved and forever remembered as bringing a championship to so many franchises but chose to be a platooned extra in New York.
Manny being.........a Ranger? If the White Sox pass the Rangers are next in line. But he just doesn't fit. Do you give up on David Murphy's excellent fielding for a loafer in the field? Do you platoon him at DH with Vlad? Manny doesn't want to be a DH and would cause problems. There might be moves to make but Manny isn't one.